This passage is a dense weave of references from the “Scylla and Charybdis” episode of James Joyce’s Ulysses. Set in the National Library of Ireland, it captures a debate on Shakespeare and mysticism.
Here is an elaboration on the figures and terms you highlighted:
The Key Figures (The Initials)
* A.E. (George Russell): A major figure in the Irish Literary Revival, a poet, painter, and committed theosophist. Joyce uses the initials “A.E.” because Russell famously used them as a pen name (derived from “Aeon”). In this scene, he represents the spiritual, mystical side of the Irish intellect, which the protagonist, Stephen Dedalus, views with some skepticism.
* K.H. (Koot Hoomi): In Theosophy, Koot Hoomi is believed to be one of the “Masters of the Ancient Wisdom” or Mahatmas. These are high-level spiritual beings who supposedly oversaw the development of the Theosophical Society. Adepts believed he lived in the Himalayas and communicated via “precipitated” letters.
* H.P.B. (Helena Petrovna Blavatsky): Mentioned at the end of your excerpt, she was the co-founder of the Theosophical Society. The “elemental” mentioned refers to a spirit or supernatural entity that followers claimed she could manifest.
Linguistic & Mystical Terms
Hiesos Kristos
This is a stylized, “esoteric” transliteration of Jesus Christ. By using “Hiesos,” Joyce is mimicking the way theosophists of the era tried to link Christian figures back to Greek, Egyptian, or Sanskrit roots to emphasize a “universal” hidden religion. Stephen describes him as a “magician of the beautiful,” viewing the religious figure through an aesthetic, artistic lens.
The “Allfather” and the “Logos”
Stephen is mentally cycling through various heresies and mystical definitions of God:
* Logos: The “Word” from the Gospel of John, but here mixed with the idea of a suffering universal spirit.
* The Fire/Sacrificial Butter: These are direct echoes of the Bhagavad Gita (specifically Chapter 9, Verse 16), where Krishna says, “I am the ritual, I am the sacrifice… I am the butter.”
The “O.P.” (Ordinary Person)
This is a bit of dry, elitist humor within the mystical circle. The “Life Esoteric” is reserved for the enlightened; the “Ordinary Person” (O.P.) is stuck in the cycle of Karma and cannot yet access the higher “plane of buddhi” (the plane of pure divine intellect).
This section of Ulysses continues the sharp intellectual sparring between Stephen Dedalus and the Dublin literati. The tone shifts from the “esoteric” mysticism of the previous passage to a clash between Platonic idealism and Aristotelian realism.
Definitions & References
“Pfuiteufel!” and the “Elemental”
The opening is Stephen’s internal mockery of the Theosophists. “Pfuiteufel” is a German exclamation of disgust (literally “Fie, devil!”). He is poking fun at the anecdote about H.P. Blavatsky’s “elemental” spirit—suggesting that looking at such a supernatural entity is as scandalous as looking at a lady’s private undergarments.
“Horseness is the whatness of allhorse”
This is Stephen’s simplified, slightly mocking take on Aristotle’s quidditas (whatness).
* Plato would argue that a physical horse is just a poor shadow of the “Ideal Horse” existing in a higher realm.
* Aristotle (the “model schoolboy”) argued that the essence of a horse exists within the horse itself.
Stephen side-steps the “eons” and “spiritual streams” of the Theosophists to focus on the concrete reality of the “here” and “now.”
“God: noise in the street”
This is one of Stephen’s most famous (and cynical) definitions. To him, God isn’t a mystical “Allfather” or an “Ineffable Name”; God is simply a random, loud event in the physical world—a shout in the street—emphasizing his move away from religious dogma toward sensory experience.
“Jubainville and Hyde”
The characters mention real-world figures of the Irish Literary Revival:
* H. d’Arbois de Jubainville: A French historian who studied Celtic mythology.
* Douglas Hyde: The author of Love Songs of Connacht and later the first President of Ireland.
* Haines: The Englishman from the first episode. His departure to buy Hyde’s book shows his “tourist” interest in Irish culture, which Stephen finds somewhat superficial.
The “Lean Unlovely English”
The rhyming quatrain at the end is a parody of the Victorian “Celtic Twilight” style of poetry. It mocks the self-conscious, overly precious way the Irish poets of the time (like A.E. or W.B. Yeats) tried to translate Gaelic sentiments into English.
This passage highlights the tension between the “mystical” Irish nationalists (represented by A.E.) and the “aesthetic” modernists (Stephen and Mr. Best).
The Verse: “Bound thee forth, my booklet…”
The verse is a bit of an internal doggerel by Stephen, mocking the style of the Irish Literary Revival.
* Interpretation: Stephen is parodying the self-deprecating, archaic tone used by Irish writers who were trying to create a “national” literature. By using words like “ween” (think/believe) and “thee,” he mocks the artificiality of their style.
* “Lean unlovely English”: This is a direct jab at the struggle of Irish writers to express Gaelic concepts in the language of their “oppressor.” Stephen implies that the result is often clunky and ungraceful.
* “Peatsmoke is going to his head”: John Eglinton suggests that the romantic, rural obsession with “peasant visions” is making these writers (or perhaps Haines) lose their grip on intellectual reality.
Etymology: Connacht
The name Connacht (or Connaught) has deep roots in Old Irish.
* Connachta: The word originally referred to a group of people, the “descendants of Conn.”
* Conn Cétchathach: This refers to “Conn of the Hundred Battles,” a legendary High King of Ireland.
* Suffix “-acht”: This indicates a collectivity or the territory belonging to the descendants of Conn.
In the context of this passage, Connacht represents the “wild West” of Ireland—the spiritual home of the “peasant on the hillside” that A.E. (George Russell) views as the source of true Irish revolution.
Key Concepts in the Dialogue
The “Auric Egg” of Russell
Stephen mocks A.E. by calling him an “auric egg.” In Theosophy, the “auric egg” is the energy field or aura surrounding a person. It suggests Russell is so wrapped up in his spiritual “bubble” that he speaks “occultly” rather than practically.
Mallarmé and the “Book of Himself”
Mr. Best brings up the French symbolist poet Stéphane Mallarmé.
* “Il se promène, lisant au livre de lui-même”: (He walks, reading the book of himself).
* This is a famous description of Hamlet. To the French symbolists, Hamlet wasn’t just a prince in a play; he was the ultimate intellectual, looking inward at his own soul rather than outward at the world.
Hamlet ou Le Distrait
The French title literally means “Hamlet, or the Distracted One.” Stephen’s witty translation—”The absentminded beggar”—is a pun on a very famous poem by Rudyard Kipling about British soldiers. He is essentially deflating the high-brow French aestheticism with a low-brow British military reference.
You’re absolutely right—in a nautical context, “to conn” (or cond) means to direct the steering of a ship. It comes from the Middle English conne, meaning “to know” or “to guide,” related to the word “conduct.”
However, in the context of the Irish province Connacht, the word has a completely different linguistic lineage. It’s a classic case of homonyms (words that sound the same but have different roots).
The Linguistic Split
| Word | Origin | Meaning |
|—|—|—|
| Conn (Nautical) | Anglo-French / Latin (conduite) | To direct the helm; to know the way. |
| Conn (Irish) | Old Irish (Conn Cétchathach) | A proper name meaning “Chief” or “Intellect.” |
Why the distinction matters in Ulysses
While the nautical “conn” isn’t the etymology of the province, the idea of “steering” and “knowing” is very “Joycean.”
* Intellect vs. Ocean: Stephen Dedalus is obsessed with language. He often plays with the fact that the Irish name Conn also translates to “sense,” “reason,” or “head.” * The Irony: A.E. and the others are talking about Connacht as a place of “peasant dreams” and “visions.” Stephen, the intellectual, likely sees the irony in a place named after “Reason” or “Headship” being used as a symbol for mystical, unthinking fog.
So, while you’re correct about the naval term, the Irish province is strictly the “Land of the Descendants of Conn.”
In this passage, Stephen Dedalus is performing a “cinematic” reconstruction of Elizabethan London, trying to make the ghost of Shakespeare feel tangible to his listeners.
Chivying
Chivying (or chivying) means to harass, nag, or persistently urge someone to move.
In this context, the “pen” (a female swan) is “chivying her game of cygnets” (her baby swans). Joyce is painting a vivid picture of a mother swan nipping at or nudging her babies toward the rushes of the riverbank.
It also serves a double purpose:
* The Literal: A natural scene on the Thames as Shakespeare walks by.
* The Figurative: It reinforces the “Swan of Avon” nickname for Shakespeare, suggesting even the wildlife in his vicinity reflects his identity, though he is too preoccupied with his own thoughts to notice them.
Key Allusions & Context
“The absentminded beggar”
This is Stephen’s sharpest joke here. It was a hugely popular poem by Rudyard Kipling, written to raise money for soldiers in the Boer War. By calling Hamlet an “absentminded beggar,” Stephen is dragging the high-brow French “Distrait” down into the muddy reality of British imperialism.
“The concentration camp sung by Mr Swinburne”
This is a chillingly prophetic line. Joyce (through Stephen) is referring to the internment camps used by the British during the Boer War. He links the “bloodboltered” (blood-matted) violence of Hamlet’s finale to the modern horrors of war, suggesting that Shakespeare’s “butcher” instincts (as a supposed butcher’s son) foresaw modern brutality.
“Sackerson” and “Canvasclimbers”
* Sackerson: A famous bear used for bear-baiting at the Paris Garden near the Globe Theatre.
* Canvasclimbers: Sailors. Stephen is populating the scene with the “groundlings”—the rough, sausage-eating sailors who sailed with Sir Francis Drake and then stood in the pit of the theatre.
“The Huguenot’s house in Silver Street”
This is a factual historical detail. Shakespeare actually lodged with a Huguenot (French Protestant) family named Mountjoy on Silver Street in London. Stephen is using “local colour” to prove his mastery of the subject to the older scholars.
In the vivid world of Ulysses, Stephen Dedalus populates his historical imagination with these rougher elements of Elizabethan life to contrast the “pure” philosophy of Plato and Aristotle.
Sir Francis Drake (c. 1540–1596)
Drake was a legendary (and, to the Spanish, notorious) English sea captain, privateer, and explorer.
* Global Explorer: He was the first Englishman to circumnavigate the globe (1577–1580) in his ship, the Golden Hind.
* Military Leader: He was second-in-command of the English fleet when it defeated the Spanish Armada in 1588.
* The “Canvasclimbers”: When Stephen mentions “canvasclimbers who sailed with Drake,” he is referring to the hardened sailors who had seen the edges of the known world and were now standing in the “pit” of the Globe Theatre, eating sausages and watching Shakespeare’s plays.
Bear-Baiting
Bear-baiting was a popular, albeit incredibly violent, blood sport in 16th and 17th-century England. It was the “action movie” of the Elizabethan era.
* The Setup: A bear (like the famous Sackerson mentioned by Stephen) would be chained to a stake in the center of a pit.
* The Action: A pack of specially bred hunting dogs (usually mastiffs) would be released to attack the bear. The “sport” was watching how many dogs the bear could fend off or kill before being overcome.
* The Location: In London, this happened mostly in the Bankside district (the Southwark side of the Thames), often in the same neighborhoods as the theaters.
Stephen mentions the bear Sackerson growling in the Paris Garden (a famous baiting arena) to emphasize that Shakespeare’s high art existed right next door to literal slaughter and animal screams. It grounds the play Hamlet in a world of raw, physical violence.
You’ve hit on exactly why Stephen Dedalus brings it up. He is trying to strip away the “polite” academic view of Shakespeare and remind his audience that the plays were written for a public that enjoyed watching a bear get torn apart by dogs.
To Stephen, the “bloodboltered shambles” of Hamlet’s final act—where almost every main character dies on stage—wasn’t just high tragedy; it was the theatrical version of a trip to the baiting pits.
Bear-Baiting vs. Modern Blood Sports
You’re right that modern sensibilities (and laws) have largely pushed these spectacles out, but the comparison of “goriness” is fascinating:
* Bear-Baiting: This was uniquely visceral because of the size of the animals. It wasn’t just a quick kill; it was a prolonged, noisy struggle involving heavy chains, snapping mastiffs, and a massive predator. It took place in a circular “arena” very similar to the layout of the Globe Theatre.
* Bullfighting: While still very controversial and bloody, it follows a strict, almost balletic ritual. In Elizabethan bear-baiting, there was no “art” to the kill—only the raw endurance of the bear.
* Cockfighting: As you noted, this persists in shadows today. It’s “less gory” perhaps only in the volume of blood, but the intensity and the gambling culture surrounding it are direct descendants of the Elizabethan pits.
The “Sackerson” Connection
Stephen mentions Sackerson by name because he was a real, “celebrity” bear of the time. Shakespeare even gives him a shout-out in The Merry Wives of Windsor, where a character brags about having seen Sackerson “loose twenty times.”
By mentioning him, Stephen is proving that Shakespeare lived in a world where humans and beasts were constantly pitted against one another. It supports his argument that Shakespeare isn’t just a “philosopher” like Plato—he’s a man who understands the “shallows” of the butcher’s shop and the bear pit.
You’ve zeroed in on the exact “nerve center” of Stephen’s argument. By noting the distinction between “I am thy father” and “I am thy father’s spirit,” you are touching on the core of Stephen’s theory about paternity.
In Stephen’s view, paternity is a legal and social “fiction”—an invisible bond that can only be proven by faith or word of mouth, whereas maternity is a physical, undeniable fact. By saying “I am thy father’s spirit,” the ghost confirms he is an absence, a memory, and a shadow.
The Theory: Shakespeare as the Ghost
Stephen’s grand “theology” of Shakespeare hinges on a few shocking claims:
* The Casting: Shakespeare (the actor) supposedly played the part of the Ghost, while the great Richard Burbage played Hamlet.
* The Real Son: Shakespeare’s only son, Hamnet, died at age eleven. Stephen argues that by playing the Ghost, Shakespeare is addressing his dead son through the living actor. He is “the murdered father” (denied his legacy) addressing “the dispossessed son.”
* The Betrayal: Stephen suggests the “Guilty Queen” (Gertrude) is actually Ann Hathaway. He believes Ann was unfaithful to Shakespeare with his brothers (Richard or Edmund), and that the plays are Shakespeare’s way of processing his domestic shame.
Key References & Terms
“As for living our servants can do that for us”
A.E. (George Russell) quotes Villiers de l’Isle-Adam, a French symbolist. This represents the “Scylla” side of the debate—the idea that art should be pure and detached from the “greenroom gossip” of the artist’s real life. A.E. thinks Stephen’s focus on Shakespeare’s debts and wife is “prying.”
“Agenbite of Inwit”
This is one of the most famous phrases in the book.
* Etymology: It is Middle English for “Remorse of Conscience” (literally: the again-biting of the inner-wit).
* Context: Stephen is feeling guilty because he borrowed a pound from A.E. and hasn’t paid it back. He spent it on a prostitute (“Georgina Johnson”).
“Molecules all change… I am other I now”
Stephen tries to use a scientific excuse to avoid his debt. Since the cells in our bodies are constantly replaced, he argues he is literally not the same physical person who borrowed the money five months ago.
“Entelechy, form of forms”
Immediately after the “molecule” joke, Stephen’s conscience snaps back. He uses the Aristotelian term Entelechy (the soul or the “vital principle” that stays the same even as the body changes). He realizes that even if his molecules change, his “I”—his memory and his sins—remains the same.
“A.E.I.O.U.”
This is a brilliant triple pun:
* The vowels of the alphabet.
* A.E., I Owe Unto: A reminder that he owes George Russell (A.E.) money.
* The motto of the Habsburg Emperors (Austriae est imperare orbi universo), mocking his own grand intellectual ambitions while he can’t even pay back a pound.
You’ve hit on a profound philosophical distinction. In the world of Ulysses, and specifically in Stephen’s Aristotelian framework, the Ghost serves as the bridge between memory and the present. If the Ghost is an “archive,” it is a dynamic and demanding archive, not a passive one. Here is how that “otherness” functions:
1. The Ghost as “The Memory of the Tribe”
For Stephen, the Ghost is the “spirit” of the past that refuses to stay buried. It represents the transmission of trauma. It is aware it is not alive, which gives it a terrifying authority: it possesses the “truth” of the past that the living (Hamlet, Gertrude, Claudius) are trying to forget or overwrite.
2. The Ghost as the “Image of the Creator”
theory. He argues that:
* The Father (The Ghost/Shakespeare): Is the “spectre” who has already lived, suffered, and been betrayed. He is the archive of experience.
* The Son (Hamlet/Burbage): Is the “action”—the one who must act upon that memory in the physical world.
By having the Ghost say “I am thy father’s spirit,” Joyce suggests that paternity itself is a ghost-story. A father is only a “father” because of a story told to the son. The Ghost is the archive of that legal and spiritual claim.
3. The “Entelechy” of the Play
Earlier, Stephen muses on Entelechy—the soul that stays the same while the body’s molecules change.
The Ghost functions as the Entelechy of the Danish Court. The bodies in the castle have changed (Claudius is now King, Gertrude is remarried), but the spirit of the true Kingdom remains in the Ghost. It is the “form” of the past that remains “by memory because under everchanging forms.”
4. The Mirror of the Artist
Finally, the Ghost is an archive for Shakespeare himself. By playing the Ghost, Shakespeare “archives” his own life—his grief for his dead son Hamnet and his resentment toward his wife Ann Hathaway. He stands on stage as a “ghost by absence” (since he is away from Stratford) and “a ghost by death,” speaking his own life’s secrets into the “ear” of the public.
This passage is a masterclass in Joyce’s ability to weave personal trauma into historical debate. Stephen is defending Ann Hathaway not because he likes her, but because he sees her as the physical reality that “made” Shakespeare—just as his own mother made him.
Here are the etymologies and definitions for the difficult terms in this section:
1. Liliata rutilantium
This is a truncated version of a Latin prayer from the Ordo Commendationis Animae (the Recommendation of a Soul to God).
* Etymology: Liliata (lilied) + rutilantium (of the shining/glittering ones).
* Context: The full phrase is “Liliata rutilantium te confessorum turma circumdet” (May the lilied throng of shining Confessors surround thee). Stephen is haunted by the prayer he heard at his mother’s deathbed, which he refused to recite.
2. Xanthippe
* Etymology: Greek Xanthos (yellow/blonde) + hippos (horse).
* Background: She was the wife of Socrates. History (largely written by men) has painted her as a “shrew” or a nagging wife. John Eglinton uses her to mock Stephen’s defense of Ann Hathaway, suggesting a nagging wife is a burden, not a “portal of discovery.”
3. Dialectic
* Etymology: Greek dialektikē (the art of debate), from dia- (across) + legein (to speak).
* Context: Stephen wittily argues that Socrates learned how to argue (dialectic) by dealing with his difficult wife.
4. Epipsychidion (and Socratididion)
* Etymology: Greek epi- (upon) + psukhē (soul/spirit). It literally means “about the little soul.”
* Context: Epipsychidion is a famous poem by Percy Bysshe Shelley about the idealization of a beloved. Stephen creates the mock-Greek name “Socratididion” (Little Socrates) to poke fun at the idea of Socrates having a “soulmate” wife in addition to his “nagging” one.
5. Absit nomen!
* Etymology: Latin. Absit (let it be absent) + nomen (the name).
* Meaning: “Far be the name!” It is a variation of absit omen (may there be no ill omen), used here because the historical existence of Socrates’ second wife, Myrto, is debated and “scandalous.”
6. Caudlelectures
* Etymology: Caudle (a warm drink for the sick/new mothers) + lecture.
* Meaning: A “curtain lecture”—a private scolding given by a wife to her husband in bed.
* Context: Stephen is saying that despite everything Socrates learned from women (his mother’s “midwife lore” and his wife’s “scoldings”), it didn’t save him from being executed by the state.
7. Archons of Sinn Fein
* Etymology: Archon (Greek for “ruler/magistrate”) + Sinn Féin (Irish for “Ourselves”).
* Context: This is a sharp, anachronistic joke. Stephen is comparing the ancient Greek judges who sentenced Socrates to the radical Irish Nationalists of his own day. He is calling the nationalists narrow-minded executioners of genius.
“Errors are the portals of discovery”
This is one of the most famous lines in the novel. Stephen is arguing that for a “man of genius,” there is no such thing as an accident. If Shakespeare married Ann Hathaway “by mistake,” that mistake was necessary to provide the “material” for his greatest tragedies.
You’ve hit on the absolute truth of Ulysses. Stephen’s “theory” is widely considered a vehicle for Joyce’s own obsession with the “human” Shakespeare. Joyce famously disliked the image of Shakespeare as a detached, god-like creator (the “Platonic” view); he preferred to see him as a man who suffered the indignities of a messy marriage, financial debt, and exile.
Here are the etymologies and the hidden logic behind Stephen’s (and Joyce’s) wordplay:
1. “Ann hath a way”
This is the most famous pun in the chapter. It’s a play on Ann Hathaway’s name.
* The Source: It actually echoes a poem attributed to Shakespeare (or his era) called “A Lover’s Complaint,” which contains the line “To teach it guide, and give it way… My Anne hath a way.”
* The Meaning: Stephen is arguing that Shakespeare didn’t “choose” his wife. She “had a way” of getting what she wanted. He was a 18-year-old boy; she was a 26-year-old woman. In Stephen’s eyes, she was the “greyeyed goddess” (Venus) who seduced the “boy Adonis” (Shakespeare) in a cornfield.
2. Etymologies & Archaic Terms
* Lollard costard:
* Lollard: (Middle Dutch lollaerd, “one who mumbles”) A follower of John Wycliffe; a heretic.
* Costard: (Old French coste, “rib”) A large type of apple, but in Elizabethan slang, it meant a person’s head.
* Meaning: Stephen is calling the bald, pink-headed librarian a “heretic head” in a playful, mock-Elizabethan way.
* Romeville: * Etymology: “Rome” (cant/slang for “great/fine”) + “ville.”
* Meaning: This was thieves’ cant (slang) for London. By using this, Stephen suggests Shakespeare arrived in the capital not as a scholar, but as a rough-and-tumble traveler with “a memory in his wallet.”
* Doxy:
* Etymology: Likely from Middle Dutch docke (doll).
* Meaning: A lover or mistress, often implying a woman of low virtue.
* Comether:
* Etymology: A contraction of “come hither.”
* Meaning: To “put the comether” on someone is an Irish idiom for using charm or persuasion to entice or “catch” them.
3. The “Boywomen” Theory
This is a crucial bit of literary criticism. Stephen (and Joyce) notes that Shakespeare’s women are often “the women of a boy.” * Historical Reality: In Shakespeare’s time, women were forbidden from the stage; young boys played the female parts.
* Stephen’s Interpretation: He argues that Shakespeare’s female characters feel “lent” their life by males. This supports his theory that Shakespeare never truly “knew” or understood women—except perhaps for the one woman who “tumbled” him in the cornfield and left him permanently scarred.
4. “If others have their will…”
This is another double-pun. Will refers to:
* William Shakespeare himself.
* Shakespeare’s Sonnet 135, where he puns on the word “Will” repeatedly (meaning desire, the name Will, and the future).
Stephen is saying that while other men have their “will” (desire), Shakespeare simply has his “Ann,” who has her “way.”
The alliteration you noticed—”Peter Piper pecked a peck of pick of peck of pickled pepper”—is a classic English tongue-twister with a long history, though Joyce playfully mangles it here to mimic Mr. Best’s “piping” voice.
History of “Peter Piper”
The rhyme first appeared in print in 1813 in a book titled Peter Piper’s Practical Principles of Plain and Perfect Pronunciation, published by John Harris in London.
* The Purpose: It was originally a pedagogical tool—an exercise to help children master the letter P.
* The Legend: Some folklorists believe “Peter Piper” was based on a real person: Pierre Poivre, an 18th-century French horticulturalist and “spice pirate” who stole cloves and nutmeg from the Dutch to grow them on his own plantation. (The “pickled peppers” in the rhyme might be a corruption of the various spices he “pecked” or pinched).
Interpretation of the Passage
Joyce uses this nursery rhyme to contrast the “quintessential triviality” of the Dublin literati with the heavy, mystical “Yogibogeybox” (Stephen’s mocking term for Theosophy) that follows.
1. “Yogibogeybox in Dawson chambers”
Stephen is mocking the Theosophical Society’s meetings. He lists their interests with total disdain:
* Isis Unveiled: A foundational book by H.P. Blavatsky.
* Mahamahatma / Aztec logos: He’s mocking their hodgepodge of Eastern and Western mysticism.
* Pineal glands aglow: A reference to the “third eye.” To Stephen, these people are just “hesouls and shesouls” swirling in a spiritual vacuum.
2. “Aristotle’s Experiment”
Stephen performs a physical trick with his index fingers on his hat (caubeen).
* The Experiment: If you cross your middle finger over your index finger and touch a small object (like a pea or the rim of a hat), it feels like there are two objects instead of one.
* The Logic: Stephen uses this to ground himself in reality. Aristotle argued that a thing is what it is (Necessity). Despite the mystical “shoals of souls” Russell talks about, Stephen asserts: “Argal (Therefore), one hat is one hat.”
Title Suggestions for your Article
Based on this latest section of Ulysses and your previous draft, here are a few titles that bridge the two:
* “Argal, One Hat is One Hat: Teaching in the Yogibogeybox” (Captures the chaos of the students and the grounding of the tutor).
* “Between the Acres of the Rye and the Bus Service Game” (Contrasts the poetic Shakespearean world with the modern student).
* “The Pineal Glands of Chhatarpur” (A witty nod to the “glowing” energy of your tutoring sessions).
This passage continues the “Scylla and Charybdis” episode, where Stephen Dedalus navigates the petty gossip and high-flown mystical talk of the Dublin intellectual elite.
1. “As in wild earth a Grecian vase”
This is a line from a poem titled “A Drover” by the Irish poet Padraic Colum.
* The Imagery: The “Grecian vase” represents classical, perfect form, while the “wild earth” represents the rugged, unpolished reality of Ireland.
* The Context: Yeats admired this line because it captured the essence of the Irish Literary Revival: the attempt to take raw, folk elements (the “wild earth”) and elevate them to the level of high art (the “Grecian vase”). It’s a direct parallel to what we discussed earlier—the struggle to find beauty in “lean unlovely English.”
2. “That Moore is Martyn’s wild oats?”
This is a sharp, witty jab involving two leaders of the Irish Literary Theatre: George Moore and Edward Martyn.
* The Metaphor: To “sow one’s wild oats” usually refers to a young man living a dissolute, rebellious, or promiscuous life before settling down.
* The Joke: Susan Mitchell (a real-life Dublin wit) suggested that George Moore—who was boisterous, scandalous, and loud—was the “wild oats” of the very pious, conservative, and Catholic Edward Martyn. It implies that Moore is the personification of all the fun and trouble Martyn was too “proper” to have himself.
* Don Quixote and Sancho Panza: The librarian further mocks them by comparing them to Cervantes’ famous duo—Moore as the delusional knight (Quixote) and Martyn as the earthy, long-suffering squire (Sancho).
Key Terms & Etymologies
* Cordoglio:
* Etymology: Italian cuore (heart) + doglia (pain/grief).
* Context: Stephen associates Cordelia (King Lear’s daughter) with the word “Cordoglio.” He is playing with the sounds of their names to link the character to deep, heartfelt sorrow. This connects back to your article’s theme of mothers and grief—Lir’s daughter in Irish myth (the Children of Lir) suffered for 900 years.
* Nookshotten:
* Etymology: An old English term (used by Shakespeare in Henry V). Nook + shotten (projected or spawned).
* Meaning: It refers to something with many corners, angles, or “nooks.” Stephen is likely using it to describe the “cornered” or fragmented nature of the conversation he is trapped in.
* Argal:
* Etymology: A corruption of the Latin ergo (therefore), famously used by the gravedigger in Hamlet. Stephen uses it to mock the “logic” of the men around him.
* Bullockbefriending:
* This is Stephen’s private nickname for Mr. Deasy (from the second episode), whom he is currently trying to help by getting a letter published in the newspaper (the “pigs’ paper”). Deasy is obsessed with foot-and-mouth disease in cattle.
Title Recommendation for your Article
Since you mentioned the “wild oats” and the contrast between your “wild” students and your academic research, a title like “Wild Earth and Grecian Vases: A Chhatarpur Tutoring Log” would be a perfect literary nod to this passage.
Dancing light of grace 